spectup logo Request Call
/ Resource hub Fundraising Process & Strategy Published Updated 14 min read

What Do Venture Capitalists Look For? Criteria and Process

What do venture capitalists look for? Five criteria with the evidence VCs ask for, the gates to closing, what diligence checks and what kills a deal.

Cover image for the VC expectations guide: a figure in a pink coat and round helmet stepping forward
What this covers
01Five criteria with the evidence for each

Team, market, traction, product and model, then cap table and financials, each tied to the document a VC asks for.

02The gates between first look and closing

First look, first meeting, partner meeting, diligence, investment committee, term sheet and closing, and where a no can come.

03A diligence checklist by document

Six areas, from cap table to option pool, each with the failure a VC looks for.

04Six causes that end a deal

Ordered by whether the company can fix the cause before outreach, with the mechanism for each.

052026 market data and return maths

Cooley's Q2 2026 round mix, NVCA's AI share and an illustrative fund showing why a VC needs outliers.

The answer to what do venture capitalists look for has five parts, in spectup's reading: a team that can execute, a market large enough to return a fund, traction that proves demand, a product and business model that scale, and a cap table and financials that survive diligence. A VC tests them across several gates, and a startup can lose the deal at any one.

This guide is for the CEO or CFO of a startup or scale-up preparing a venture round, and for the founders who sit with them.

Figure 01IllustrativeA VC deal passes five gates before the term sheet, and it can end at any of themThe gates a venture deal passes between first look and closing, and where it can end.
A VC deal passes five gates before the term sheet, and it can end at any of themA flow of the gates in a VC investment decision. First look, first meeting, partner meeting, diligence and investment committee follow in that order. The company can hear no at every gate. A yes at the investment committee leads to the term sheet and closing, which the company and its counsel negotiate.First lookdeck read against the fund's thesisFirst meetingteam and storyPartner meetinga partner decides to sponsorNopossible at every gateDiligencethe evidence behind the claimsInvestment committeememo and voteTerm sheet and closingthe company and its counsel negotiateA VC deal passes five gates before the term sheet, and it can end at any of themA flow of the gates in a VC investment decision. First look, first meeting, partner meeting, diligence and investment committee follow in that order. The company can hear no at every gate. A yes at the investment committee leads to the term sheet and closing, which the company and its counsel negotiate.First lookdeck read against the fund's thesisFirst meetingteam and storyPartner meetinga partner decidesto sponsorNopossible at every gateDiligencethe evidence behind the claimsInvestmentcommitteememo and voteTerm sheetand closingthe company and itscounsel negotiate
Figure 01 data: A VC deal passes five gates before the term sheet, and it can end at any of them
StepLeads to
First look (deck read against the fund's thesis)First meeting; No
First meeting (team and story)Partner meeting; No
Partner meeting (a partner decides to sponsor)Diligence; No
No (possible at every gate)end
Diligence (the evidence behind the claims)Investment committee; No
Investment committee (memo and vote)Term sheet and closing; No
Term sheet and closing (the company and its counsel negotiate)end
Source: the order funds typically follow, as described in this chapter. It varies by fund.

What do venture capitalists look for in a startup? The five criteria and how each is tested

The best evidence on how investors weigh these criteria is a survey. The NBER working paper that asks how do venture capitalists make decisions polled 885 institutional VCs at 681 firms. In selecting investments, they see the management team as more important than product or technology.

The survey was first circulated in 2016 and later appeared in the Journal of Financial Economics. It records what VCs say they do and describes practice as it stood then, so this guide prints no weight per criterion.

The five criteria are spectup's grouping of the survey and of the documents VCs ask for. What it supports is a test per criterion, and the table sets each test against the evidence a VC asks for.

Criterion

What the VC tests

Evidence the VC asks for

Team

Whether these people can execute and adapt when a hypothesis fails

Founder history, shipped work, the equity and role split, references

Market

Whether the market is large enough to return the fund if the company wins

Bottom-up sizing from customer counts and price, named competitors

Traction

Whether demand is real and repeats

Revenue or usage by cohort, retention, pipeline against signed contracts

Product and model

Whether the product earns money in a way that scales

Pricing, gross margin, unit economics, a roadmap tied to customer demand

Cap table and financials

Whether the numbers survive a line-by-line check

Cap table, convertible notes, option pool, monthly accounts, burn and runway

A weak cap table row can be repaired before outreach; a weak team row can only be explained.

What do VCs look for in founders?

A product can change after the investment, and the team has to carry it through the change. The same survey reports that VCs credit the team with more of the likelihood of success or failure than the business itself.

VCs check three things on the team slide:

  • Domain history: years in the market, and the customers or employers that show access to it. A VC reads this as a shortcut for how many mistakes the team has already paid for elsewhere.

  • Shipped work: what the team built, sold or raised before, and what came of it. A product that was shut down is evidence too, if the team can say what it learned.

  • The split: who holds the equity, who holds which role, and what happens if one person leaves. A split that leaves a key founder with little equity is a retention problem the VC will price in.

References close the loop. Calls with former colleagues, customers and earlier investors test whether the story on the slide matches how the team is described when it isn't in the room.

If the team slide is the weak point, a startup fundraising consultant can show where the gaps sit before the first partner meeting. The video below, Your Team Slide is Killing Your Pitch Deck, covers the slide itself.

What do VCs look for in the product and the business model?

A VC reads the product through its economics: what customers pay, what each sale costs to serve and whether the price holds against competitors. Gross margin shows how much of each sale stays after delivery, and unit economics show whether the company earns back what it spends to win a customer. A roadmap tied to what customers ask for shows what the team builds next.

How do VCs size a market and test traction?

A VC sizes the market against the size of the fund. A fund returns its capital through a few large winners, so the investor asks whether this market could hold a company big enough to be one of them.

A VC wants a count it can rebuild bottom-up: the customers the company can reach times the price it can charge. Top-down figures from analyst reports don't say anything about that price or reach, so the VC rebuilds the number and compares it with the deck.

Illustrative example: a company sells to 4,000 reachable customers at $25,000 a year, which makes its reachable market $100M a year. A slide that quotes a market in the tens of billions hides that gap, and the VC's next question is whether $100M a year can produce a venture-sized outcome or whether a second product has to carry the company there.

What investors look for in startups shifts with the round, and funds draw the lines differently: the survey finds that practice differs across industry, stage, geography and past success.

The metrics a VC trusts are the ones it can rebuild from the company's own data: usage, retention and revenue by cohort. The key metrics investors look for in startups define each of them.

For a first institutional round, the Series A traction benchmarks cover the proof the investor asks for.

How do VCs make investment decisions, step by step?

Venture capital investment decisions run through a sequence of gates, and a company can lose the deal at any of them. In the NBER paper How Do Venture Capitalists Make Decisions?, VCs rated sourcing, selection and post-investment support, and they put deal selection first, which puts the weight on the gates below. The order varies by fund, as the chart at the top of this guide shows.

At the first look, someone in the fund reads the deck against the fund's thesis and stage. A company that reaches a partner whose thesis fits the round has a sponsor from day one, and one that lands in a general inbox has to earn one.

The first meeting tests the team and the story. The partner meeting tests whether a partner will carry the deal to the rest of the fund. A partner who carries a deal defends it in front of the other partners, so the committee asks the same questions.

VCs took about three in four first meetings across 37 client raises, says spectup's study of who takes investor meetings.

Diligence then checks the evidence behind what the partner heard, and in a fund with an investment committee the vote follows a written memo. The partner writes the memo from the deck, the meetings and the diligence findings.

The company controls less at each later gate. At the first look it controls the deck and the route in. At diligence it controls only whether its documents agree with each other, which is why the preparation sits before outreach.

Figure 02IllustrativeFrom the partner meeting on, the fund decides and the company's part is the documentsWhat the company and the fund each do at the five gates, in order.
From the partner meeting on, the fund decides and the company's part is the documentsA swimlane of the five gates by who acts at each. At the first look the company sends the deck and the fund reads it against its thesis. At the first meeting the company presents and the fund tests the team and the story. At the partner meeting a partner decides whether to sponsor the deal and defends it to the other partners. In diligence the company supplies documents and the fund checks them against the deck. At the committee stage the fund writes the memo and votes. From the partner meeting on, the fund decides and the company's part is the documents.First lookFirst meetingPartner meetingDiligenceCommitteeCompanyFundDeckSends thedeck, orfinds a routeto a partnerScreenReads thedeck againstthe thesisand stagePitchPresents theteam andthe storySponsorA partnerdecideswhether tosponsor thedeal anddefends itto the otherpartnersData roomSupplies thedocumentsbehind theclaimsFindingsChecks thedocumentsagainst thedeckVoteWrites thememo and,where thefund has acommittee,votes on itFrom the partner meeting on, the fund decides and the company's part is the documentsA swimlane of the five gates by who acts at each. At the first look the company sends the deck and the fund reads it against its thesis. At the first meeting the company presents and the fund tests the team and the story. At the partner meeting a partner decides whether to sponsor the deal and defends it to the other partners. In diligence the company supplies documents and the fund checks them against the deck. At the committee stage the fund writes the memo and votes. From the partner meeting on, the fund decides and the company's part is the documents.CompanyFundFirst lookDeckSends the deck, or findsa route to a partnerScreenReads the deck againstthe thesis and stageFirst meetingPitchPresents the teamand the storyPartner meetingSponsorA partner decideswhether to sponsorthe deal and defendsit to the other partnersDiligenceData roomSupplies the documentsbehind the claimsFindingsChecks the documentsagainst the deckCommitteeVoteWrites the memo and,where the fund has acommittee, votes on it
Figure 02 data: From the partner meeting on, the fund decides and the company's part is the documents
PhasePartyStep
First lookCompanyDeck: Sends the deck, or finds a route to a partner
First lookFundScreen: Reads the deck against the thesis and stage
First meetingCompanyPitch: Presents the team and the story
Partner meetingFundSponsor: A partner decides whether to sponsor the deal and defends it to the other partners
DiligenceCompanyData room: Supplies the documents behind the claims
DiligenceFundFindings: Checks the documents against the deck
CommitteeFundVote: Writes the memo and, where the fund has a committee, votes on it
Source: the gates as set out in this section. The order and the roles vary by fund.

From the desk. spectup counts $760M+ advised, raised or placed. A food technology operator in Asia, $18M Series B, is on its list of startup rounds closed, and the investor outreach spectup ran for it produced 44 investor meetings.

After a yes, the term sheet sets price and terms, and the founders' counsel negotiates them with the fund's counsel. Closing follows once the final documents are signed and the money arrives.

A startup raise runs 5 to 8 months. Plan the runway for the longer end of the range.

What do venture capitalists look for in due diligence?

VC due diligence is the investor's check that the company matches its deck. It has three strands: financial diligence reads the accounts and the cap table, legal diligence reads contracts, IP assignments and the corporate record, and commercial diligence calls customers and tests the market claim. Each strand ends in findings that go into the committee memo.

It runs on documents, and the gaps it finds sit where one document contradicts another: the cap table against the deck, revenue against contracts, the option pool against the hiring plan.

Area

What the VC asks for

What makes it fail

Cap table

Fully diluted table, every holder, vesting terms

Holders or share counts that differ from the deck or the last round

Notes and debt

Every convertible note, SAFE and loan, with caps, discounts and maturity

A note the deck leaves out, or terms that change ownership at conversion

Revenue

Revenue by customer against signed contracts and bank statements

Revenue booked without a contract, or tied to one customer

Customers

Reference calls with named customers

A reference who can't confirm the use case or the price

IP

Assignment agreements from every founder and contractor

Code or product built by someone who never assigned the rights

Option pool

Size, grants made, shares left

A pool too small for the planned hires, which pushes dilution onto existing holders

The table doubles as the VC due diligence data-room index. Investor due diligence covers the full request list and who answers each item, and every row above should have its document in the folder before the first partner meeting.

A finding doesn't always end the deal. A cap table mismatch that the company explains and corrects within a day becomes a line in the memo. The same mismatch found by the investor first becomes a question about what else is wrong, so disclose before the VC finds it.

Rebuild the cap table in a cap table calculator before the folder opens, so the numbers the VC rebuilds are the numbers you sent.

What kills a VC deal?

The committee needs a reason to say yes that a partner can repeat to the other partners. These six causes end raises. The first three show up in a document review, the next two need rework and the last can only be reduced:

  1. A cap table that contradicts the deck. The investor rebuilds ownership from the documents, and a different answer reads as carelessness or concealment.

  2. A convertible note nobody mentioned. It changes ownership at conversion, so the investor's stake ends up smaller than the term sheet says.

  3. Revenue with no contract behind it. The number can't be tied to a customer, so the traction criterion fails after the fact.

  4. A deck that oversells the product. The first demo shows the gap, and every other claim is re-read as exaggeration.

  5. A market size with no bottom-up logic. Without customers times price, the investor can't test whether the market could return the fund.

  6. Runway shorter than the VC's timetable. A company that needs the money soon can't wait for a committee, and it gives up its room to negotiate.

Figure 03IllustrativeThree of the six deal killers are document problems, and a review before outreach finds all threeSix causes that end VC deals, by when each surfaces in the process and by how far the company can fix it before outreach.
Three of the six deal killers are document problems, and a review before outreach finds all threeA two-axis chart of six deal killers by the gate where each surfaces and by how far the company can fix it before outreach. A cap table that contradicts the deck, a note left out of the deck and revenue with no contract are document problems that surface in diligence, and a review before outreach finds all three. A deck that oversells the product and a market size with no bottom-up logic surface early and need rework. Runway shorter than the VC's timetable surfaces last, when the timetable meets the company's cash, and can only be reduced.Fixable before outreach →Only reducedSurfaces at a later gate →First meetingCap table vs deckNote left outRevenue, no contractDeck oversellsMarket, no bottom-upRunway under timetableThree of the six deal killers are document problems, and a review before outreach finds all threeA two-axis chart of six deal killers by the gate where each surfaces and by how far the company can fix it before outreach. A cap table that contradicts the deck, a note left out of the deck and revenue with no contract are document problems that surface in diligence, and a review before outreach finds all three. A deck that oversells the product and a market size with no bottom-up logic surface early and need rework. Runway shorter than the VC's timetable surfaces last, when the timetable meets the company's cash, and can only be reduced.Fixable before outreach →Only reducedSurfaces at a later gate →First meetingCap table vs deckNote left outRevenue, no contractDeck oversellsMarket, no bottom-upRunway under timetable
Figure 03 data: Three of the six deal killers are document problems, and a review before outreach finds all three
ItemFixable before outreach (0 to 100)Surfaces at a later gate (0 to 100)Note
Cap table vs deck9290
Note left out8676
Revenue, no contract6684
Deck oversells5828
Market, no bottom-up4412
Runway under timetable1096
Illustrative placement of this article's own sorting by gate. Positions within a band are not scaled.

The first three are document problems. A data-room review finds all three before outreach: the company can correct the cap table and disclose the note, and revenue without a contract needs the contract or a restated figure.

The deck and market-size problems need rework, which takes longer. Runway is the one cause a company can only reduce, by cutting burn or starting earlier, and it decides when to begin the raise at all.

What do venture capitalists look for in returns and exits?

A venture fund is underwritten on a few large winners. Hamilton Lane's primer on venture investing says it can be common for one or two investments to offset dozens of losses, so the investor works backward from the exit a check has to reach.

Illustrative example: a $100M fund makes 20 investments of $5M. Twelve fail and return nothing, six return their cost, one returns 3x and one returns 20x. The six at cost bring back $30M, the 3x brings $15M and the 20x brings $100M, so the fund gets back $145M and the single 20x investment supplies about 69% of it.

Figure 04IllustrativeOne 20x investment brings back $100M of the illustrative fund's $145MIllustrative fund: $100M in 20 investments of $5M. Twelve write-offs return nothing; six return their cost, one returns 3x and one 20x.
One 20x investment brings back $100M of the illustrative fund's $145MA waterfall of an illustrative $100M fund's proceeds from 20 investments of $5M. Six investments returning their cost bring back $30M, one at 3x adds $15M and one at 20x adds $100M, for $145M in all. Twelve write-offs return nothing.$0$50M$100M$150M$30MSix investmentsat cost+$15MOne at 3x+$100MOne at 20x$145MProceedsOne 20x investment brings back $100M of the illustrative fund's $145MA waterfall of an illustrative $100M fund's proceeds from 20 investments of $5M. Six investments returning their cost bring back $30M, one at 3x adds $15M and one at 20x adds $100M, for $145M in all. Twelve write-offs return nothing.$0$50M$100M$150MSix investments at cost$30MOne at 3x+$15MOne at 20x+$100MProceeds$145M
Figure 04 data: One 20x investment brings back $100M of the illustrative fund's $145M
StepChangeRunning total
Six investments at cost$30M
One at 3x+$15M$45M
One at 20x+$100M$145M
Proceeds$145M
Illustrative example from this article.

For $100M to come back from a $5M check, the stake has to sell for 20 times its cost. At an illustrative 10% ownership at exit, that's a company worth $1B, and a market that can't hold a company of that size ends the conversation at the first look.

The VC asks whether a success would be big enough to matter to the fund, since a modest success barely moves the result. Venture capital investment decisions therefore start from the exit and work back to the check size and the entry price.

What does the 2026 venture market look like?

Capital in 2026 is concentrated. NVCA's Q3 2026 Venture Monitor reports that AI companies accounted for 82.7% of US venture deal value through September, the highest annual share in its dataset, with activity driven largely by AI and a handful of outsized rounds.

That's a share of dollars and says nothing about how a fund scores a company outside AI.

Cooley handled 166 financings in Q2 2026. In its report, up rounds, priced above the previous round, were 83.6% of deals, down rounds 12.1% and flat rounds 4.3%.

Figure 05Up rounds were 83.6% of the deals in Cooley's Q2 2026 reportShare of deals in Cooley's Q2 2026 report by price against the previous round.
Up rounds were 83.6% of the deals in Cooley's Q2 2026 reportA donut chart of venture financings in Cooley's Q2 2026 report, by price against the previous round: up rounds 83.6%, down rounds 12.1%, flat rounds 4.3%.83.6%Q2 2026Cooley reportUp roundsDown roundsFlat roundsUp rounds were 83.6% of the deals in Cooley's Q2 2026 reportA donut chart of venture financings in Cooley's Q2 2026 report, by price against the previous round: up rounds 83.6%, down rounds 12.1%, flat rounds 4.3%.83.6%Q2 2026Cooley reportUp roundsDown roundsFlat rounds
Figure 05 data: Up rounds were 83.6% of the deals in Cooley's Q2 2026 report
WholePartShare
Q2 2026Up rounds83.6%
Q2 2026Down rounds12.1%
Q2 2026Flat rounds4.3%
Source: Cooley, Q2 2026 Venture Financing Report, as cited above. Shares of deals as Cooley reports them.

The same report puts a 1x liquidation preference in 95.8% of deals. It gives the investor the right to recover its money once before common shareholders are paid.

My direct assessment: preparation is what a VC can score

The survey ranks the team first. The gates reward whatever a VC can check, and that is where I'd put the hours: documents, customers who pick up the phone and numbers that tie out.

The team is the factor a company can change least before outreach: what it can do is explain it. The other four criteria rest on documents and numbers the company controls, even where the VC judges them by bottom-up logic or cohorts.

Of the five criteria, the cap table is the one most within a company's control.

How spectup runs a startup raise

spectup works for the startup raising the money and brings the investors to the table, and it doesn't act for the VC. The work has four steps:

  1. Map the criteria to the materials. spectup reads the deck and data room against the five criteria and flags where one document contradicts another before any VC sees them.

  2. Build the investor list by thesis and stage fit. The list draws on investor data from spectup's closed transactions and on its own signal engine, which watches 80+ triggers that show when an investor's capital is becoming allocatable, for example a fund closing or a partner changing firms.

  3. Book the partner meetings. Outreach is aimed at the partner whose thesis fits the round, the first-look point from the gates above.

  4. Prepare the client for the term sheet. spectup prepares the client and its counsel for the term sheet negotiation. The client's counsel negotiates the terms with the fund's counsel.

Three layers of network sit behind the list. Closed transactions gave spectup 440+ direct relationships. Across client processes it has presented to 2,500+ investors and LPs, and 30+ partner firms bring their own investors in on a shared transaction.

The fee is a retainer plus a fee due when the round closes and the client receives the money.

What do venture capitalists look for before you start pitching?

Start outreach when three checks pass, in this order, because each is cheaper to repair before a VC has seen it:

  1. The evidence file is complete. Every row of the diligence table has a document behind it, and the deck figures tie to the accounts.

  2. The cap table matches the deck. Same holders, same notes, same pool.

  3. Runway covers the committee's timetable. The company can wait for a vote without a bridge.

If the deck is the weak point, the pitch deck service rebuilds it once the figures tie out. If one of the three checks fails, fix it before your first email goes out.

/ Insights

Three conclusions

01
A VC scores the evidence it can check

The survey puts the team ahead of product and technology, but the vote follows a memo built from documents. A startup controls whether the documents the memo will draw on agree with each other when the first partner meeting starts.

02
Diligence ends deals the pitch won

Gaps appear where two documents disagree: the cap table and the deck, or revenue and contracts. A document review before outreach finds them first.

03
Fund maths sets the minimum market

A fund lives on a few outliers, so the investor works backward from the exit a check must reach. A market that can't hold that company ends the conversation at the first look.

/ Answers

What do venture capitalists look for: questions readers ask

7 questions on fundraising process and strategy, answered by Niclas Schlopsna, Managing Partner.

01What do venture capitalists look for in a startup?

A team that can execute, a market large enough to return a fund, traction that proves demand, a product and model that scale, and a cap table and financials that survive diligence. In the survey of 885 VCs, the team outranks product.

02What do VCs look for in founders?

Domain history, shipped work and a clear split of equity and roles. The NBER survey finds investors credit the team with more of the odds of success or failure than the business. Expect questions on how the team handled its last wrong hypothesis.

03What do VCs look for in a pitch deck?

Evidence for each of the five criteria: the team, the market size, traction, the model and a cap table that ties to the accounts. Every figure has to tie to the accounts, since diligence reads the deck against them.

04What metrics do VCs look for in startups?

The ones a VC can rebuild from the company's own data: usage, retention and revenue by cohort. The definitions behind each are in the key metrics guide, and the benchmarks depend on the round.

05How do VCs make investment decisions?

A fund reads the deck against its thesis, holds a first meeting and takes the company to a partner meeting. Diligence then checks the documents behind the claims, and in a fund with a committee the vote follows a written memo. A yes brings a term sheet, and closing follows once the final documents are signed. Each gate can end the deal, so the company's evidence has to be ready before the first one.

06What should a startup not tell investors?

Anything the documents contradict. A document review before outreach finds a cap table that differs from the deck, a note the deck leaves out and revenue the contracts don't support. The company can correct the cap table and disclose the note, and revenue without a contract needs the contract or a restated figure. A market size needs customers times price before it goes in the deck.

07When should a startup hire a startup fundraising consultant?

When the company needs investors it can't reach alone, or when its deck and data room still contradict each other. spectup works for the startup raising and brings the VCs to the table. The company and its counsel handle the terms. spectup's record is $760M+ advised, raised or placed.

Niclas Schlopsna, Managing Partner at spectup
Written by

Niclas Schlopsna

Managing Partner

Started spectup in Berlin in 2022 and runs the commercial side of it: which engagements the firm takes, how a raise or a sale is positioned, and what the market hears about it. On a live process he sets the range with the client and prepares them for the negotiation.

LinkedIn
Where you are12 sections